Monday , May 12, 2025

More Debit Card Use Translates Into More Debit-Based Returns, PSCU Data Finds

The holiday shopping season may be over, but the holiday returns are coming in at full force. Data from PSCU, a credit union service organization, showcases the impact the rise in e-commerce spending is having on returns. Return purchases using debit cards were up 76.2% for the week ending Jan. 3, compared to the week ending Jan. 5, 2020. Returns using credit cards were up 19.4% year-over-year for the same period.

“While returns are up considerably year over year, increases were expected given the significant growth in [card-not-present] purchases, which typically see returns up to three times higher than [card-present] purchases,” PSCU’s Tracking Transaction Trends report noted. “Additionally, shipping companies generally predict Jan. 2 as the highest day for return volume as consumers emerge from the holiday period.” Mastercard Inc. reported in late December that e-commerce sales volume grew by 49% year-over-year in the Oct. 11 to Dec. 24 period.

Average return amounts increased, too. Debit card returns in the goods sector averaged $55.49, a 16.3% increase from last year, while credit card returns averaged $75.95, up 8.5%.

Overall, for the week ending Jan. 3, U.S. spend was up 21.1% for debit purchases and credit increased 6.1%.

Through the holiday shopping season from Nov. 2 through Dec. 27, PSCU says purchases made with debit cards was up 26.2% and up 18.1% for credit cards within the retail goods sector. Card-not-present purchases in the sector were up 55.8% for credit cards and up 38.7% for debit cards.

In related news, St. Petersburg, Fla.-based PSCU renewed a 32-year-old payment-processing agreement with Brookfield, Wis.-based Fiserv Inc. PSCU says the 1,500 credit unions it services handle more than 5.4 billion transactions annually.

Check Also

Financial Institutions Press Their Case Against Illinois’s Interchange Law

Plaintiffs in the lawsuit challenging the Illinois Interchange Fee Prohibition Act are pushing hard to …

Digital Transactions